Nominations Queries, Part I

[longficmod]

Nominations are pouring in! We will make a decision on the MCU-related TV shows soon--please leave any final comments here if you have a preference.

In the meantime, please remember to check the formatting guidelines at that same post before you nominate. Let us know if anything looks incorrect in the tagset. If you need us to change something with the tags you nominated, please include a link to your personal nominations page.

We have some questions we're hoping you can help us resolve. Again, if these are your nominations, please include a link to your noms page:

Avatar: The Last Airbender, Group: Zuko/Ozao (ATLA) - Should this be Ozai?

Supernatural (TV 2005), Group: Sam Winchester & Creator's Choice of Villain - Are you specifically looking for a canonical villain? If so, may we add "Canonical" to the tag?

Crossover Fandom, Group: Nebula (MCU)/Nebula (MCU) - Is this a MCU nomination or a crossover between MCU Nebula and another version?

Naruto, Fandom should be "Dreaming of Sunshine - Silver Queen (Fanfic DFE)" but AO3 changed it - Please comment with a link to your nominations page. There are a lot of other nominations for Naruto, and we don't know which are yours and are supposed to be for DoS.

The Walking Dead & Related Fandoms, Group: Felix Carlucci/Will Campbell, Group: Rick Grimes/Daryl Dixon - We also have nominations for The Walking Dead (TV). Should these be combined? If not, can we separate this nomination into World Beyond and Walking Dead?

16th Century CE RPF, Historical RPF - The characters nominated in these two fandoms have no overlap, but we'd like to avoid having both century-specific and general historical RPF fandoms in the tagset, and the general historical one spans a few centuries. Are there any objections to combining these? We're looking at a pretty small number of tags (7 total).

Star Trek - Various Authors, Group: Alexander Rozhenko/Giancarlo Wu, Group: Elim Garak/Kelas Parmak - We already have Pawns and Symbols in the tagset. What's the best way to handle that as well as these novel-related nominations?

Transformers - All Media Types - Please nominate a specific media type.

Horizon: Zero Dawn (Video Game), Group: Aloy & Beta, Group: Aloy & Kotallo, Zo (Horizon: Zero Dawn) - Should these be nominated under Zero Dawn or Forbidden West?

Comments

[sheliak]

Hi, one of the DoS nominators here!

I originally nominated as
Dreaming of Sunshine - Silver Queen (Fanfic DFE)

The interface told me that one of my noms (Group: Nara Shikako & Uchiha Shisui (DoS)) was already in the tagset under another fandom:
Dreaming of Sunshine - Silver Queen (DFE)

So I changed the fandom to match that (I assumed that'd make things easier on the mod end—perhaps incorrect!) and switched the character slot to something else.

On my nom page the fandom is still showing up as Dreaming of Sunshine - Silver Queen (DFE), not synned to Naruto. I suspect that what you saw was me changing the name, not AO3 doing so!

ETA: I checked, and "Dreaming of Sunshine - Silver Queen (Fanfic DFE)" isn't getting changed to Naruto either.

My noms:
https://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/10615/nominations/237364

[longficmod]

Hi! This is a separate issue--the nominations on your page should be approved under the correct fandoms (including "Dreaming of Sunshine - Silver Queen (DFE)"), but please let us know if they don't look right.