Tagset Clarifications Post 1

[longficmod]

Nominations are flowing in! Please let us know if you spot errors or duplicates.

Before we can approve the following tags, we have questions for the nominators. Please include a link to your nominations page with your reply so we can confirm these are your tags.

Howl's Moving Castle - All Media Types - we also have a nomination for the animated film. Can you specify whether you want the film version or the book?

Wiedźmin | The Witcher - All Media Types - we also have nominations for the TV series and video games. Could you please specify which version you’re interested in?

Harry Potter - J.K. Rowling - we have nominations for Assaf Kowalski-Riemann, Annabelle Crestley, Francesca Lam, John Kowalski, and Mikael Kowalski which do not appear to be Harry Potter characters. May we ask you to nominate them into the correct fandom?

Pokemon - we have nominations for Pocket Monsters | Pokemon (Main Video Game Series), Pocket Monsters: Ruby & Sapphire & Emerald | Pokemon Ruby Sapphire Emerald Versions, Pocket Monsters: Scarlet & Violet | Pokemon Scarlet & Violet Versions, and Pokemon Colosseum & XD. Should Ruby, Sapphire, Emerald, Scarlet, and Violet go under the Main Video Game Series?

Wolf In Night - Tara K. Harper - AO3 suggests that the canonical tag for this fandom may be Wolfwalker Series - Tara K. Harper. Should we change it to this?

Comments

[senmut]

Not the nominator, but book and movie are vastly different for Howl's Moving Castle. I mean obviously elements like characters, and broad plot points, but as a requestor and writer I would likely avoid the AMT for it, without very explicit letters to guide which is wanted.

[silverwill]

Hi

I nominated some Pokemon pairs under the Pokemon Scarlet & Violet fandom. I'm cool with them going under the Main Video Game Series

[longficmod]

Thank you! Could you send us a link to your nominations page so we can see which tags are yours?

[silverwill]

here you go: https://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/14770/nominations/278845

[shadaras]

Not the nominator, but the characters you listed as incorrectly being in the Harry Potter fandom are from The Revolutionary Arc - kitsunerei88, which is a recursive fanfic that gets synned to Harry Potter by ao3. The nominator probably did try to nominate it under the correct name, but without adding a "DFE"-type tag.

[(Anonymous)]

Hi, Revolutionary Arc is a recursive fic Harry Potter series/fandom. I saw Dreaming of Sunshine tags, so assumed that recursive fandoms were accepted for this exchange.

All of the nominated characters and relationships are canonical within that verse, (John Kowalski and Francesca Lam both already have canonical Ao3 tags).I put Revolutionary Arc - kitsunerei88 as the fandom when I submitted the nominations, but the Ao3 system automatically converted that to Harry Potter - J.K. Rowling

[(Anonymous)]

I otherwise used the "Character: Character A (fandom)" format as instructed, appending (Revolutionary Arc) and not (Harry Potter) behind each character name. Please inform me if additional detailing or edits are required.

[(Anonymous)]

And here is the link to my nominations

https://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/14770/nominations/279109

[(Anonymous)]

in the video game section, 真女神転生IV FINAL | Shin Megami Tensei IV: Apocalypse shows up twice in the tagset

[(Anonymous)]

Hi, it looks like the nominations for The Martian (2015) got duplicated.

[longficmod]

Thank you! We've updated the fandom for those nominations. They'll appear as rejected on your nominations page, but you can see them in the tagset under Revolutionary Arc (fanfic) - kitsunerei88.

[longficmod]

Thank you! Should be fixed.

[longficmod]

Thank you! That should be fixed.

[longficmod]

Yes, we'll definitely need the nominator to tell us what they want on this one!

[longficmod]

Thank you, we have that sorted with the nominator now!

[(Anonymous)]

Heads up - in the Other Media Section, it seems that every relationship tag in the All Elite Wrestling fandom is duplicated.

Pokemon

[ysavvryl]

I had the nominations for Pokemon Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald and Colosseum/XD. The RSE ones could go under the MVGS tag if that would make things easier. One reason I had for nominating them separately is that Pokemon MVGS tends to get a big exchange tagset that is difficult for me to read on AO3. Separate listings would make it easier to tell which characters belong to which games too, even if the Pokemon and some characters show up in multiple generations. But if the MVGS group is already there, that's fine with me.

I do think that the Colosseum/XD should remain separate because one group I put in was Wes and his Espeon and Umbreon, to make it clear that the group is those particular Pokemon and not just any Espeon and Umbreon.

Duplicate tags

[(Anonymous)]

There's a lot of duplicates in A Song of Ice and Fire and Avatar: The Last Airbender - it looks like a bunch of tags have gone in twice.

[longficmod]

Thank you, that should be fixed!

Re: Duplicate tags

[longficmod]

Thank you--I think we've fixed those, but let us know if we missed any!

Re: Pokemon

[longficmod]

Thank you! We've approved under MVGS and Colosseum/XD.