2025 Nominations Clarification Post 2

[longficmod]

Nominations closing in about an hour! I'll reopen the tagset when signups start. That will happen 3 May at the latest.

Please leave a comment if you see any errors, duplicates, misspellings, etc. in the tagset. If you're commenting about your own nominations, please include a link to your nominations page.

Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon:

• We already have Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Anime & Manga) in the tagset. Is it okay to combine your nomination into the Anime & Manga version? If not, what version are you looking for?

House of the Dragon (TV):

• For Aegon Targaryen/Aemond "One-Eye" Targaryen (HotD) and Aegon Targaryen/Aemond "One-Eye" Targaryen/Helaena Targaryen (HotD), is this specifically Aegon II Targaryen and not Aegon III?
• Character: Cannibal the Wild Dragon (HotD): Can someone confirm that Cannibal has appeared in the show?

Hunger Games Series - All Media Types:

• We already have nominations for the book trilogy and for Sunrise on the Reaping as their own fandoms. Can you please specify whether you're looking for the books or the films?

Marvel Cinematic Universe, WandaVision, Agatha All Along:

• We have nominations for Wanda/Vision under both MCU and WandaVision. Can both nominators comment on whether they're hoping to draw on both the films and the TV show?
• We have a nomination for Agatha Harkness & Wanda Maximoff under MCU, as well as separate nominations for the fandoms WandaVision and Agatha All Along. My understanding is that Agatha doesn't appear in the films. Can the nominators comment on what they're hoping for?

Original Work:

• Character named Jake/Character named Bradley - I try not to be too prescriptive about OW nominations, but I don't think character names without any descriptions are enough for this fandom! Can you explain what you're going for here?
• Exasperated Male Vampire & Reckless Male Firefighter (OW) and Exasperated Vampire & Reckless Firefighter (OW) - are these the same nominator? Does the nominator of the second tag have a gender preference?

Star Trek: Discovery

• We have nominations for Original Universe Gabriel Lorca and also for Gabriel Lorca | Mirror Gabriel Lorca. These are the canonical tags. I don't know the fandom--does Gabriel Lorca refer only to the mirror version, or would it be clearer to have the second set of tags just say Mirror Gabriel Lorca?

The Transformers (IDW Generation One)

• We already have Transformers Generation One in the tagset. Are these separate fandoms?

Wiedźmin | The Witcher - All Media Types:

• Due to the differences between the different media types, please specify whether you're looking for the books, the games, or the TV show.

Comments

Sailor Moon

[(Anonymous)]

We already have Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Anime & Manga) in the tagset. Is it okay to combine your nomination into the Anime & Manga version? If not, what version are you looking for?

If this is mine, then yes, that's fine!

Re: Sailor Moon

[longficmod]

I can check if it's yours--can you send me a link to your nominations page?

Re: Sailor Moon

[longficmod]

Never mind, I see the nomination has been updated, thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

Hi there--on the Witcher nomination (which is mine (https://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/23284/nominations/374458)) can you please set it to the games? Thank you!

[longficmod]

Done, thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

I did the Discovery noms, and I think it would be easier to go with Original Universe Gabriel Lorca and Mirror Gabriel Lorca.

[longficmod]

Thanks, will do!

[shadaras]

If you're going to remove the Lorca piping, retaining Mirror Gabriel Lorca will be clearer (especially in contrast to Original Universe Gabriel Lorca).

(in canon we never meet Original Universe Gabriel Lorca; we only meet Mirror Gabriel Lorca pretending to be the original one.)

[longficmod]

Thank you, that makes sense! I wasn't set on removing the piping, mostly wanted to confirm the different nominations were in fact different characters, but from the nominator it sounds like removing the piping is fine.

[stillturningout]

Nominator for Vampire and firefighter! I did nom both, the male ones were supposed to be / while the general non-gendered one was supposed to be &, hope that's still possible :)

[longficmod]

Got it! Approved that way--please let me know if it doesn't look right

[smiles_edgeworth]

Hi! I noticed a duplicate in "Arcane: League of Legends (Cartoon 2021)":

Caitlyn Kiramman & Jayce Talis (Arcane 2021)
Jayce & Caitlyn (Arcane)

[longficmod]

Thank you, that's fixed!

[(Anonymous)]

Wandavision nominator for W/V ! I think moving it under the films would be fine. The show references the films quite heavily.


Also in regards to Transformers, G1 and IDW are different! They are two different universes with different characterizations and plotlines.

[longficmod]

Thanks! Did you nominate just Wanda/Vision and not Wanda/Agatha?

[(Anonymous)]

Yep! Just W/V.

[callmesandyk]

Hi, can I ask why Tom Holland Spider-man is listed under cartoons? I assume it's an error you haven't got to yet, but I did want to note it's absolutely separate canon from the recent mcu cartoon friendly neighborhood Spider-man.

[longficmod]

Hi, thanks for asking! The media category for each fandom is actually set by AO3 and not something exchange mods have control over. This fandom seems to have been categorized under Cartoons as well as Movies--it appears in both sections.

[(Anonymous)]

sorry just saw this.

Character named Jake/Character named Bradley

the thought was I could get a random AU for my ship out of this 😂 you can just nix it, thanks!

[longficmod]

Got it, thanks. :) You're welcome to nominate archetypes of your ship for OW, but the names alone might lead to a mismatch in expectation between requests and offers.

Duplicate

[(Anonymous)]

It looks like there's some duplicates in the tagset for Top Gun?

Bradley "Rooster" Bradshaw/Jake "Hangman" Seresin (TG)
Bradley "Rooster" Bradshaw/Jake "Hangman" Seresin

They're the same thing.

Re: Duplicate

[longficmod]

Thank you, those should be fixed!