Nominations are closed

[chocolateboxmod]

Nominations have closed! The tagset is here and, outstanding some further queries, is mostly done.

First up, we have some queries:

Crossover Fandom, Group: Nebula (MCU)/Nebula (MCU) - Could the nominator please come forward and confirm whether this this a MCU nomination or a crossover between MCU Nebula and another version?

Violet Evergarden G: Gilbert Bougainvillea Violet Evergarden & Claudia Hodgins (VE) - what relationship do you want between Gilbert and Violet?

Final Fantasy VII We have nominations for Crisis Core, Final Fantasy VII, and Compilation of Final Fantasy VII. Nominators, do you want these merged into one nomination? Alternatively, nominator for the Compilation, do you want to specify a game?

The Lord of the Rings - AMT We already have nominations for the books. May we ask you to pick a version?

The Walking Dead & Related Fandoms - can the nominator for this please come forward and confirm if you are happy for this to be included into The Walking Dead (TV)?

If you see any tags that need correcting, please let us know! Please note however that if a fandom is in the wrong media category (or is in the Uncategorized Fandom category) we can't do anything about that, as that is done on AO3's end.

Comments

[sirvalkyrie]

Agatha Harkness (WandaVision) is showing up under Marvel Comics.

Group: Kira Nerys/Keiko O'Brien/Miles O'Brien and Group: Kira Nerys/Keiko O'Brien/Miles O'Brien (ST: Deep Space Nine) are the same ship, both under Deep Space Nine.

[(Anonymous)]

Is it me or are half of the Star Wars tags duplicated?

[chocolateboxmod]

There's a bug that sometimes tags get duplicated. If you can tell us which ones are duplicated, we can remove them.

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed now!

[flipflop_diva]

There are some duplicates under DC's Arrowverse. These are the ones I noticed (after I stared at them for 5 minutes trying to see if they were different):

Group: Beth Kane | Alice/Mary Hamilton (DC's Arrowverse)
Group: Clark Kent/Lois Lane/John Henry Irons (DC's Arrowverse)
Group: Gwyn Davies/Behrad Tarazi (DC's Arrowverse)
Group: Rip Hunter & Booster Gold (DC's Arrowverse)

[withthekeyisking]

Under Miracle Workers (TV) this tag is a duplicate: "Group: Benny the Teen/The Gunslinger (Miracle Workers)"

[klutzygirl]

There are duplicated tags in The Cleaning Lady (TV)

Group: Thony De La Rosa/Arman Morales (The Cleaning Lady)

Group: Thony De La Rosa/Arman Morales & Luca De La Rosa (The Cleaning Lady)



Lost In Space (TV 2018) also has some duplicates:

Group: John Robinson/Maureen Robinson/Don West (Lost in Space 2018)

Group: John Robinson/Maureen Robinson/Grant Kelly (Lost in Space 2018)



And all the tags in Wings (TV 1990) managed to duplicate themselves too:

Group: Brian Hackett & Joe Hackett (Wings TV 1990)

Group: Casey Chappel Davenport & Helen Chappel (Wings TV 1990)

Group: Casey Chappel Davenport/Brian Hackett (Wings TV 1990)

Group: Helen Chappel/Joe Hackett (Wings TV 1990)

[(Anonymous)]

Some more duplicated tags:

Psmith - P. G. Wodehouse (2)
Group: Mike Jackson/Psmith (Psmith)

Scanners (1981) (2)
Group: Darryl Revok/Cameron Vale (Scanners)
Group: Darryl Revok/Cameron Vale (Scanners)

The Mysterious Benedict Society - Trenton Lee Stewart (7)
Group: Ledroptha Curtain & S.Q. Pedalian
Group: Ledroptha Curtain & S.Q. Pedalian
Group: Nicholas Benedict & Constance Contraire
Group: Nicholas Benedict & Constance Contraire
Group: Nicholas Benedict/Ledroptha Curtain Group: Nicholas Benedict/Ledroptha Curtain

[headstone]

Some tags which are appearing in duplicate within the tagset (not duplicates of each other):

人渣反派自救系统 - 墨香铜臭 | The Scum Villain's Self-Saving System - Mòxiāng Tóngxiù:
Group: Liu Mingyan/Sha Hualing (SVSSS)
Group: Liu Qingge/Luo Binghe (SVSSS)

天官赐福 - 墨香铜臭 | Tiān Guān Cì Fú - Mòxiāng Tóngxiù:
Group: He Xuan/Shi Qingxuan (TGCF)
Group: Yin Yu/Quan Yizhen (TGCF)

泾渭情殇 - 请君莫笑 | Clear and Muddy Loss of Love - Qǐng Jūn Mò Xiào:
Group: Nagsi Jiya/Nangong Shunu (Clear and Muddy Loss of Love)
Group: Qi Yan | Qiyan Agula/Nangong Jingnu (Clear and Muddy Loss of Love)
The Masked Person | Li Yanru (Clear and Muddy Loss of Love)

Also, "Jiang Cheng (Untamed)" and "Jiāng Chéng | Jiāng Wǎnyín (Modao Zushi)" are both showing up under 陈情令 | The Untamed (TV); only the former belongs there (the latter is also showing up under 魔道祖师 - 墨香铜臭 | Módào Zǔshī - Mòxiāng Tóngxiù and can be deleted from The Untamed).

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed now!

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed now!

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed now!

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed now!

[chocolateboxmod]

We think we've fixed those! In terms of Jiang Cheng, can I ask you to take a look to see if they're right? We had to effect the changes several times to get them to stick.

[(Anonymous)]

I was the one who nominated the compilation of FF7. I'd be fine with putting the Sephiroth and Seph/Zack tags in Crisis Core, and the Reno& Rude and Turks tags in Final Fantasy VII?

[headstone]

Thanks for doing that! Yep, that all looks fine to me. Whether or not there are tone marks or piping in the tag is superfluous for nomination/tagset purposes as long as there's one of him in each MDZS and The Untamed.

[headstone]

Oh, but sorry to be the bearer of bad news: I either missed some the first time around or you have some new duplicates popping up in The Untamed...

Group: Jiang Cheng/Nie Huaisang (The Untamed)
Group: Nie Huaisang/Jin Guangyao (The Untamed)
Group: Jin Guangyao/Nie Mingjue (The Untamed)

ED: and a few more in different fandoms...

棋魂 | Hikaru no Go (Live Action TV)
Group: Shi Guang/Yu Liang (Hikaru no Go)

山河令 | Word of Honor (TV 2021)
Group: Luo Fumeng/Liu Qianqiao (Word of Honor)
Group: Xie Wang/Liu Qianqiao (Word of Honor)
Group: Zhou Zishu/Jin Wang (Word of Honor)

了不起的女孩 | Dear Missy (TV)
Group: Lu Ke/Shen Si Yi/Yao Yuan/Zhang Mang (Dear Missy)
Group: Lu Ke/Zhang Mang (Dear Missy)

[chocolateboxmod]

Those duplicates should be removed now!

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be in the tagset now!

[klutzygirl]

Great, thank you!

[morbane]

Format issues:

The Grisha Trilogy - Leigh Bardugo
Character: Nikolai Lantsov (TGT)
should be
Nikolai Lantsov (TGT)

The Shadow Campaigns - Django Wexler
Character: Winter Ihernglass (Shadow Campaigns)
should be
Winter Ihernglass (Shadow Campaigns)

Monty Python RPF
Character: Michael Palin (Monty Python RPF)
should be
Michael Palin (Monty Python RPF)

This Way Up (TV)
Character: Shona (This Way Up)
should be
Shona (This Way Up)

鬓边不是海棠红 | Winter Begonia (TV)
Character: Ning Jiulang (Winter Begonia)
should be
Ning Jiulang (Winter Begonia)

The Nice House on the Lake (Comics)
Character: Walter (The Nice House on the Lake)
should be
Walter (The Nice House on the Lake)

Horizon: Zero Dawn (Video Game)
Character: Vala (Horizon: Zero Dawn)
should be
Vala (Horizon: Zero Dawn)

For convenience's sake, comma-separated list of same:

Nikolai Lantsov (TGT),Winter Ihernglass (Shadow Campaigns),Michael Palin (Monty Python RPF),Ning Jiulang (Winter Begonia),Walter (The Nice House on the Lake),Vala (Horizon: Zero Dawn),Shona (This Way Up)


Different wrong tag format:
League of Legends
Relationship: Sylas/Lux (League of Legends)
should be
Group: Sylas/Lux (League of Legends)

This tag is wandering from
Horizon: Zero Dawn (Video Game)

原神 | Genshin Impact (Video Game)
Aloy (Horizon: Zero Dawn)

These tags have been duplicated within their fandom:

The Tudors (TV)
Group: Anne Boleyn/Thomas Cromwell/Henry VIII of England

Star Wars Original Trilogy
Group: Luke Skywalker & Leia Organa & Han Solo (SW OT)
Group: Luke Skywalker/Leia Organa/Han Solo (SW OT)

Rockman DASH Series | Mega Man Legends
Ira (Mega Man Legends)
Teisel Bonne (Mega Man Legends)
Tron Bonne (Mega Man Legends)
[weirdly Mega Man Volnutt is the only non-duplicated tag here]


I'm not sure, but I wonder if this tag is correct?

Kingdom Hearts (Video Games)
Group: Ventus/Vantias (Kingdom Hearts)

There's already
Group: Vanitas/Ventus (Kingdom Hearts)

in the tag set, and I can't find a Vantias by googling. Are they an alternate character? Sure seems possible with Kingdom Hearts. Or are they a typo?


In
Bunny - Mona Awad
I think:
Group: va/Samantha Heather Mackey
should be
Group: Ava/Samantha Heather Mackey

Also in
David Blaize - E. F. Benson
Group; Hughes/Frank Maddox
should be
Group: Hughes/Frank Maddox

[desertvixen]

Dupes in Star Wars Original Trilogy

Group: Luke Skywalker & Leia Organa & Han Solo (SW OT)
Group: Luke Skywalker/Leia Organa/Han Solo (SW OT)

[beleghir]

I nominated Lord of the Rings AMT - happy to change that to the books and have it join the rest of the tags.

[(Anonymous)]

Merlin (TV) has two versions of the same tag:
Group: Arthur/Merlin (Merlin) -- this one should get deleted
Group: Merlin/Arthur Pendragon (Merlin)

The rest of these show up twice in their tagsets:
Miracle Workers (TV)
Group: Craig Bog/Eliza Hunter/Sanjay Prince (Miracle Workers)

Sinbad (TV)
Group: Gunnar/Sinbad

The Borgias (Showtime TV)
Group: Rodrigo Borgia & Ascanio Sforza

The Afterparty (TV 2022)
Group: Yasper/Aniq (The Afterparty)
Group: Yasper/Xavier (The Afterparty)
Group: Zoe/Chelsea (The Afterparty)

Phantom of the Opera - Lloyd Webber
Original Female Character(s) (Phantom of the Opera)

[longficmod]

Thank you--those should be fixed!

[longficmod]

Thank you! We've updated that and approved the relationship nominations.

[longficmod]

Thank you! I think those are all fixed now.

[longficmod]

Thank you! Those should be fixed now.

[morbane]

thanks!

One more wanderer - Aurora (Sleeping Beauty 1959) is appearing in Maleficent instead of just Sleeping Beauty (1959) where she should be.

[(Anonymous)]

Hi, I nominated the Violet Evergarden one. It's missing a / - the perils of C&P, sorry.

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed now!

[chocolateboxmod]

Not a problem - that's been sent through now!

[(Anonymous)]

Hello, there's a spelling error in the Naruto tag!

'Group: Hoshigake Kisame/Momochi Zabuza (Naruto)' should be 'Group: Hoshigaki Kisame/Momochi Zabuza (Naruto).'

[(Anonymous)]

I nominated The Walking Dead & Related Fandoms and I am happy for them to be included in The Walking Dead (TV)

[tarlanx]

Apologies - that anon is me - had to change browsers as Firefox is being a real pain and not loading DW pages!

[longficmod]

No worries! What we've done is approved Group: Felix Carlucci/Will Campbell under World Beyond, then rejected Group: Daryl Dixon/Rick Grimes, as that was also nominated under the original TV show and is approved there. Please let us know if the resulting tags aren't what you were hoping for!

[longficmod]

Thank you, that should be fixed!

[tarlanx]

That's perfect!