Nominations Queries, Part 3

[longficmod]

Nominations are closed, and signups will open on 5 April! Please continue to let us know if you spot errors or duplicates–we are working through quite a few tags that have been doubled.

The following tags still need replies from nominators. Please include a link to your nominations page. If we don’t hear from the nominators, these tags may be rejected.

Howl's Moving Castle - All Media Types - we have both the film and the book in the tagset. Can you specify which version you want?

Wiedźmin | The Witcher - All Media Types - we also have nominations for the TV series and video games. Could you please specify which version you’re interested in?

Brave (2012), Cinderella (Disney Animated Movies), and The Little Mermaid (Disney Animated Movies) - The relationships for these fandoms are all crossovers between different Disney movies. Please leave a comment with your nominations page so we can resolve this.

American Girl Dolls - All Media Types - For the tag “Molly McIntire & Steve Rogers”, please confirm whether Steve Rogers is an American Girls character.

Addams Family - All Media Types - This is another “All Media Types” fandoms with widely divergent adaptations. Could the nominator please clarify which one they want, including a link to the nominations page? Further, Lydia Deetz is a character in Beetlejuice and Velma Dinkley is a character from Scooby Doo.

​​Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling - These all appear to be nominations for the Rigel Black fanfiction–can the nominator please confirm their intent, including a link to their nominations page?

Star Wars Original Trilogy - Ahsoka Tano doesn’t appear in the Original Trilogy. Can the nominator please leave a link to their nominations page and confirm which Star Wars fandom they wanted for these tags, or whether they want a crossover?

Compilation of Final Fantasy VII - This nomination appears to be a crossover. Please comment with a link to your nominations page to resolve.

The Lord of the Rings - J. R. R. Tolkien - Can the nominator confirm whether Alatar & Pallando appear in Lord of the Rings as characters?

Comments

[xslytherclawx]

Not the nominator, but I have extensive canon familiarity and can confirm Steve Rogers is NOT an American Girl character.
Most likely this was meant to go under crossovers (I’m assuming it’s MCU Steve Rogers, since Molly is the WWII girl, but only the actual nominator can answer that).

[longficmod]

Thank you! We'll hope to hear from them.

[(Anonymous)]

The Blue Wizards (Alatar and Pallando) are mentioned in Two Towers but not by name, just as part of the 5 Istari. Tolkien only gave them names later on, but they're technically present in the LOTR world.

Would it be better to put them under Silmarillion?

[longficmod]

Yes, if someone would need to read Silmarillion to request or write those characters, they'd be better under that fandom. We've moved them there!

[shetiger]

Under TV - Andor (TV) there are two doubled tags: Cinta Kaz/Vel Sartha (Andor)Cinta Kaz/Vel Sartha (Andor)Mon Mothma/Dedra Meero (Andor)Mon Mothma/Dedra Meero (Andor)

[longficmod]

Thank you, those should be sorted now!

[jiang_pengji]

I was the one who nominated the Rigel Black fanfiction tags—I nominated them under "Rigel Black Chronicles - murkybluematter", which is a fandom tag, but the archive automatically corrected that to Harry Potter, (I assume) since that is its parent tag.

I would prefer to have them listed seperatley, rather than as part of the Harry Potter fandom, if possible.

Also, completely seperatley, in another one of my nominations under Dungeons and Dragons: Honor Among Thieves (2023) I misspelt a character's name—the tag "Szass Tam & Serephina" should be "Szass Tam & Sofina"—hopefully you can fix this!

Here is my nominations page: https://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/14770/nominations/279847

[longficmod]

Thank you, those should all be approved/fixed! Your RBC noms will appear as rejected on your personal page, but they should be available in the tagset itself.

[miss_ingno]

Music & Bands -> Dreamcatcher (Korea Band) has Kim Minji | JiU/Kim Yoohyeon (Dreamcatcher) and Kim Minji | JiU/Kim Yoohyeon, which I think happened because my nominations for the Deja Vu by Dreamcatcher MV were moved to the band section? (I had Jiu/Yoohyeon and Jiu & Yoohyeon both under Deja Vu. The confusion might be because someone else nominated the same tag as character!Jiu/character!Yoohyeon? Which is what I intended with my noms, too, but I'm unfamiliar with the character!tag terminology)

TV Shows -> 琅琊榜 | Nirvana in Fire -> Consort Jing (Nirvana in Fire) & Lin Shu | Mei Changsu | Su Zhe + Consort Jing & Lin Shu | Mei Changsu | Su Zhe is doubled up, too.

[longficmod]

Thank you for clarifying! Sorry, that got a bit mixed up, as we had nominations for the band overall as well, and they were appearing in both fandoms. Please let us know if the current tags are correct based on what you had nominated.

[miss_ingno]

Yes, the current tags are fine! Thank you and sorry for the confusion <3

[(Anonymous)]

Duplicate under Star Trek: The Next Generation:
Beverly Crusher/William Riker/Deanna Troi (ST: TNG)
Beverly Crusher/William Riker/Deanna Troi (ST:TNG)

Also under Star Trek: Picard, "Geordie La Forge & Soji Asha (ST:PIC)" should be Geordi.

[longficmod]

Thank you, those are sorted!

[polyalice]

Sorry, just saw this. But for Howls I was thinking the film.

[longficmod]

Thank you--we've approved it as the film.

Tag Duplicates

[(Anonymous)]

Hi, I noticed there were some duplicates in the Gravity Falls tag:

Bill Cipher & Mabel Pines (Gravity Falls)
Bill Cipher & Mabel Pines (Gravity Falls)
Bill Cipher & Pines family (Gravity Falls)
Bill Cipher & Pines family (Gravity Falls)
Bill Cipher & Stanford Pines & Stanley Pines (Gravity Falls)
Bill Cipher & Stanford Pines & Stanley Pines (Gravity Falls)
Bill Cipher/Stanley Pines (Gravity Falls)
Bill Cipher/Stanley Pines (Gravity Falls)

Re: Tag Duplicates

[longficmod]

Thank you, those are fixed!